Award Abstract # 1560810
CAREER:Perceptual Narrowing and Cortical Development in Infancy

NSF Org: BCS
Division of Behavioral and Cognitive Sciences
Recipient: UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA
Initial Amendment Date: September 18, 2015
Latest Amendment Date: September 18, 2015
Award Number: 1560810
Award Instrument: Continuing Grant
Program Manager: Uri Hasson
BCS
 Division of Behavioral and Cognitive Sciences
SBE
 Directorate for Social, Behavioral and Economic Sciences
Start Date: September 10, 2015
End Date: June 30, 2018 (Estimated)
Total Intended Award Amount: $202,503.00
Total Awarded Amount to Date: $202,503.00
Funds Obligated to Date: FY 2014 = $130,726.00
FY 2015 = $71,777.00
History of Investigator:
  • Lisa Scott (Principal Investigator)
    lscott@ufl.edu
Recipient Sponsored Research Office: University of Florida
1523 UNION RD RM 207
GAINESVILLE
FL  US  32611-1941
(352)392-3516
Sponsor Congressional District: 03
Primary Place of Performance: University of Florida
FL  US  32611-2002
Primary Place of Performance
Congressional District:
03
Unique Entity Identifier (UEI): NNFQH1JAPEP3
Parent UEI:
NSF Program(s): Cognitive Neuroscience
Primary Program Source: 01001415DB NSF RESEARCH & RELATED ACTIVIT
01001516DB NSF RESEARCH & RELATED ACTIVIT
Program Reference Code(s): 1045, 1187, 1698, 1699
Program Element Code(s): 169900
Award Agency Code: 4900
Fund Agency Code: 4900
Assistance Listing Number(s): 47.075

ABSTRACT

Before six months of age, infants readily perceive differences between faces within both familiar (e.g., own-race) and unfamiliar (e.g., other-race) groups. Importantly, by 9 months of age, they have lost ability for perceiving differences between other-race faces. This loss in perceptual ability is called "perceptual narrowing" and is theoretically driven by the experiences infants have interacting with some groups of people more than others. With funding from the National Science Foundation, Dr. Lisa Scott, working at the University of Massachusetts, is carrying out research to understand how perceptual experience and brain maturation interact during infancy to result in brain and face recognition specialization. During a brief period of infancy, perceptual biases are formed, apparently, leading to long-lasting deficits in face recognition and identification of individuals within unfamiliar or less frequently encountered groups. Recent research suggests that perceptual narrowing arises when infants do not learn to associate individual names, such as "Sue" or "Bob," with people of other races. Faces from racial groups with which infants do not interact, faces that remain nameless, are perceived as one undifferentiated category. Dr. Scott is investigating how different perceptual experiences influence the development of underlying brain regions responsible for face perception and face processing biases, which lead to difficulties identifying and remembering people within another race and to difficulties perceiving and interpreting social and emotional face information. Dr. Scott hypothesizes that learning the names of faces or objects at the individual level rather than at the category level leads to qualitatively distinct brain representations and more discriminative behavioral responses. She expects that perceptual narrowing is driven primarily by experience and not brain maturation. In her studies, infants and their families receive books with labeled images of faces and objects, and the families are asked to read these books to their infants for three months. Infant learning is examined by measuring whether or not infants of different ages can differentiate between trained and new images never seen before, and by using eye tracking to measure where they focus on the images. Brain activity is recorded before and after training to determine whether learning names influences neural responses to faces and objects. Dr. Scott predicts that learning the names of faces also results in enhanced development of face processing beyond face recognition, including emotion and gaze perception.

While much is known about brain maturation within the first year of life, less is known about how experience and learning affect specialized neural responses and abilities. The results of this project are expected to lead to a better understanding of how infants tune their perceptual systems in an ever-changing world, and how specific early experiences influence later perceptual abilities. The outcome of this research is expected to have implications in the area of developmental disorders such as Autism, and in the understanding of social interactions and social biases. Understanding the development of face recognition can help explain relationships between race perception and social prejudice. The results can be used to inform parents, educators, and policy makers about perceptual learning and the role of experience on the developing brain. Cognitive neuroscience methods are becoming increasingly important tools in infant development research, so the next generation of scientists need expertise with these techniques. Dr. Scott is implementing a summer research experience program that aims to introduce high school, undergraduate, graduate, and post-doctoral students to scientific inquiry in cognitive neuroscience and methods used to study brain development. This program aims to assist aspiring young scientists in developing their academic and career goals, facilitate and encourage students to form mentoring relationships and networks, and teach students about the importance of community outreach, education, and the responsible dissemination and communication of research findings.

PUBLICATIONS PRODUCED AS A RESULT OF THIS RESEARCH

Note:  When clicking on a Digital Object Identifier (DOI) number, you will be taken to an external site maintained by the publisher. Some full text articles may not yet be available without a charge during the embargo (administrative interval).

Some links on this page may take you to non-federal websites. Their policies may differ from this site.

Barry-Anwar, R., Hadley, H., Conte, S., Keil, A. & Scott, L.S "The developmental time course and topography of individual-level face discrimination in the infant brain." Neuropsychologia , v.108 , 2018 , p.25 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2017.11.019
Barry-Anwar, R., Hadley, H. & Scott, L.S "Differential Neural Responses to Faces Paired with Labels Versus Faces Paired with Noise at 6- and at 9-months" Vision Research , 2018 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.visres.2018.03.002
Hadley, H., Pickron, C. & Scott, L.S. "The Lasting Effects of Process-specific versus Stimulus-specific Learning During Infancy" Developmental Science , 2015 10.1111/desc.12259
Hadley, H., Rost, G.C., Fava, E. & Scott, L.S. "A Mechanistic Approach to Understanding Cross-Domain Perceptual Narrowing in the First Year of Life." Brain Sciences , 2014 10.3390/brainsci4040613
Markant, J. & Scott, L.S. "Attention and Perceptual Learning Interact in the Development of the Other-Race Effect" Current Directions in Psychological Science , 2018 10.1177/0963721418769884
Pickron, C., Fava, E. & Scott, L.S. "Follow My Gaze: Face Race and Sex Influence Gaze-cued Attention in Infancy." Infancy , 2017
Pickron, C., Iyer, A. Fava, E. & Scott, L.S. "Learning to Individuate: The specificity of labels differentially impacts infants? attention" Child Development , v.89 , 2018 , p.698 https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.13004

PROJECT OUTCOMES REPORT

Disclaimer

This Project Outcomes Report for the General Public is displayed verbatim as submitted by the Principal Investigator (PI) for this award. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this Report are those of the PI and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation; NSF has not approved or endorsed its content.

Intellectual Merit: The results from this project has has significantly contributed to our understanding of infant behavioral and neural development during the first year of life.

We conducted longitudinal investigations that followed infants across the second half of the first year of life to better understand the extent to which infants learn from shared book reading with parents.  In one of these experiments we found that when parents read infants books with specifically labeled names for faces, or objects, infants learn more and show more specialized brain responses. This is in contrast to books with no labels or books with the same generic label under each image in the book. More specifically, we reported that when infants were given 3 months of shared book reading experience with books in which novel objects were labeled with individual-level names, they increased their attention to these objects as well as new objects they had never seen before. Consistent with other reports, this study suggests that for infants, finding books that name different characters may lead to higher quality shared book reading experience and result in the learning and brain development benefits we have reported. In addition, learning from 6-9 months of age was shown to impact both behavioral and brain measures 3 years later in children highlighting the importance of early learning on later child development.

Results from this project have also begun to uncover the complexities underlying how specific experiences during infancy lead to better recognition of faces within familiar groups relative to unfamiliar groups (i.e., other-race effect/bias). Previous findings suggest that although early in infancy babies can tell apart people within multiple races, with development and experience, their face recognition abilities become tuned to groups of people they interact with the most, a process we have called “perceptual narrowing”. Findings from across two cross-sectional investigations and one longitudinal investigation specifically identified the lack of individual-level labeling/naming as an important contributor to perceptual narrowing and the development of face processing biases. 

Perceptual narrowing may also influence infants’ abilities to utilize other aspects of face processing, such as emotion recognition and their ability to make inferences about social intentions. Two experiments within this project found that the decline in ability to recognize other-race faces during infancy impacts the ability 1) to perceive facial emotions and accurately match emotion sounds with images of emotion faces and 2) to follow eye gaze cues to learn about objects.  We also found that infants shift their processing of face-related emotion information from anterior to more posterior neural regions from 5- to 9-months of age. This shift in neural processing is noteworthy because it suggests that perceptual narrowing may be the result of a shift in processing from attention based systems to perceptually based systems, not simply just a refinement of a broad perceptual system. This work led to a recently published model, I-MAP (Interactive Model of Attention and Perceptual Learning), to account for the development of the other-race face bias.  I-MAP  proposes a mechanistic interaction between the development of attention systems and perceptual learning that is impacted by developmental tasks including: visual, language, and motor development, as well as the development of attachment relationships.

Broader Impacts: The overarching educational goal of this project was to increase women and underrepresented minority participation in developmental cognitive neuroscience. Trainees at several levels were involved in this project including 2 White female post-doctoral fellows, 2 White female graduate students, a White female international visiting graduate student, an Black American female and an Black American male graduate student, a Southeast Asian male graduate student, over 25 undergraduates of multiple races and ethnicities, and an Black American male high school student. In addition to being involved in the research, this project implementing a summer research experience program that aimed to introduce high school, undergraduate, graduate, and post-doctoral students to scientific inquiry in cognitive neuroscience and methods used to study brain development. This program assisted aspiring young scientists in developing their academic and career goals, facilitated and encouraged students to form mentoring relationships and networks, and taught students about the importance of community outreach, education, and the responsible dissemination and communication of research findings. An evaluation of this summer program suggested it was effective at promoting professional development and that peer mentoring was a particularly important factor for self-reported program satisfaction.  

In addition to training impacts, results from this project have been disseminated broadly through conference and invited presentations, published journal articles, a series of press-releases and several media interviews, two Science 360 spotlights, and most recently an article published in The Conversation highlighting the importance of early infant-parent book reading that was published in over 50 local, national, and international news outlets.   

 

 


Last Modified: 06/26/2018
Modified by: Lisa S Scott

Please report errors in award information by writing to: awardsearch@nsf.gov.

Print this page

Back to Top of page